Active

$858,000

5737 Butternut Drive
Lewis Center, OH 43035

Evans Farm

4
Beds: 3.5
Baths: 2,994
Sq Ft: 0.18
Acres: 2 car
Garage

About this home

5737 Butternut Dr in Evans Farm offers 2,312 square feet (2,994 including the partially finished basement) on a spacious lot, with a light, bright layout and high-end finishes throughout. The first-floor office at the front of...

List price: $858,000
Original list price: $899,900
Days on market: 92 days
Annual property taxes: $4,335 / year
Year built: 2026

MLS # 20260729134002613321000000 · Listed by Jamie L Maze · Fiv Realty Co Ohio LLC · Listed Aug 1, 2026 · Updated Oct 30, 2026

Property details

Listing overviewMLS-approved public listing fields

MLS number: 226028512
Status: Active
List price: $858,000
Original list price: $899,900
List date: Aug 1, 2026
Property type: Residential
Property subtype: Single Family Residence
County: Delaware
Township: Orange
Subdivision: Evans Farm
Parcel number: 318-210-23-012-000

TaxesMLS-approved public listing fields

Annual property tax: $4,335
Tax year: 2,025

Rooms and interiorMLS-approved public listing fields

Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 3.5
Full bathrooms: 3
Half bathrooms: 1
Living area: 2,994 sq ft
Finished area: 2,994 sq ft
Basement: Yes
Fireplace: Yes

Exterior and lotMLS-approved public listing fields

Lot size: 0.18

ParkingMLS-approved public listing fields

Garage spaces: 2
Garage type: Yes

AssociationMLS-approved public listing fields

HOA fee: $45
Frequency: Monthly
Fee: $45
Fee frequency: Monthly

SchoolsMLS-approved public listing fields

School district: OLENTANGY LSD 2104 DEL CO.

Listing and showing informationMLS-approved public listing fields

Listing office: Fiv Realty Co Ohio LLC
Listing agent: Jamie L Maze
Co-listing agent: Erin Edwards
Public remarks: 5737 Butternut Dr in Evans Farm offers 2,312 square feet (2,994 including the partially finished basement) on a spacious lot, with a light, bright layout and high-end finishes throughout. The first-floor office at the front of the home provides flexible space for work or other use. The open-concept great room features a stacked-stone gas fireplace with a wood mantel, a modern ceiling fan, and large windows that fill the space with natural light. The kitchen includes a large quartz island, custom shaker cabinetry, a tile backsplash, stainless steel range hood, matte black fixtures, and glass pendant lighting, opening to a dining area with sliding door access to the covered patio. Wide-plank wood flooring runs throughout the main level. A half bath completes this floor. Upstairs, 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms include a primary suite with a double-sink quartz vanity, black fixtures, and a large tiled walk-in shower. The finished basement adds a fourth bedroom, a full bathroom with a tiled glass-enclosed shower and dark quartz vanity, a bar, and a recreation space. Additional features include forced-air gas heat, central air conditioning, a poured foundation, cement fiber board exterior, and a 2-car attached side-load garage. The builder is offering a $4,000 appliance allowance and a $2,000 closet allowance. Evans Farm includes shops, restaurants, parks, and walking paths.

Provider and sourceMLS, status, agent, brokerage, and dates

MLS number: 20260729134002613321000000
Status: Active
MLS: Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listing office: Fiv Realty Co Ohio LLC
Listing agent: Jamie L Maze
List date: Aug 1, 2026

Location & neighborhood

Alum Creek Elementary School5/5 stars0.8 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Arrowhead Elementary School4/5 stars1.1 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Olentangy High School5/5 stars1.1 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Heritage Elementary School5/5 stars1.2 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Olentangy Shanahan Middle School5/5 stars1.3 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment

View more schools

Data details

District attendance-area locator

District: Olentangy Local School District

Closest schools are ranked by straight-line distance from official NCES public-school building locations. Proximity does not determine attendance assignment or enrollment. Independently verify every school and attendance assignment with the district.

Open source

Census Tract 115.62; Delaware County; Ohio

Area housing context

Data details

U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey

Geography: Census Tract 115.62; Delaware County; Ohio
GEOID: 39041011562
Period: 2020–2024 ACS five-year estimates
Retrieved: Oct 31, 2026
Median owner-occupied value: $529,300 ± $32,206

Census tract estimates describe an area, not a person or household. ACS estimates have sampling error and should not be used to steer, rank protected classes, or make eligibility decisions.

Open source

Housing units: 3,035
Occupied: 97%
Owner occupied: 91%
Median year built: 2014
Median gross rent: $1,191

How this home fits the Lewis Center market

Payment estimate

Estimated monthly housing cost

Home price$Down payment%Loan termInterest rate%Property taxes / year · MLS$Home insurance / year · Estimated$HOA/COA fees / month · MLS$

Estimated monthly payment

$5,102

Estimated loan amount: $686,400

Principal & interest: $4,339
Property taxes: $361
Home insurance: $358
HOA/COA fees: $45

Planning estimate only—not a loan offer, official Loan Estimate, or insurance quote. Confirm actual costs with your lender and other providers.

Estimate details

Insurance starts at a planning estimate of 0.5% of the home price per year. Items shown as “Not included” are excluded from the total. The estimate does not include closing costs, utilities, maintenance, special assessments, or every lender and escrow charge; mortgage insurance may also apply based on the loan.

Similar homes in Lewis Center

View all homes

Two-story exterior with horizontal siding, a covered front porch featuring tapered columns, and oversized multi-pane windows

Price Drop

$939,000

5129 Maple Drive

Lewis Center, OH

4 beds3.5 baths3,474 sq ft

0.3 mi away
Same area
Same single family residence style
Similar price

$864,000

2022 Leopold Drive

Lewis Center, OH

4 beds3.5 baths3,024 sq ft

0.4 mi away
Same area
Same single family residence style
Similar price

Price Drop

$779,900

2261 Woodstock Avenue

Lewis Center, OH

4 beds3.5 baths2,848 sq ft

0.1 mi away
Same ZIP
Same single family residence style
Similar price

Back on Market

$699,999

5117 Maple Drive

Lewis Center, OH

4 beds3.5 baths2,396 sq ft

0.3 mi away
Same area
Same single family residence style
Similar price

Your local advisor

Clint Ford

Team Lead, REALTOR®

+16143525645

Home details

Review this home.

The property record is loading. You can return to current homes or contact the team at any time.

View current homes Talk with an agent

Current information

Loading current details…

The page is ready to use. Provider-backed homes and market evidence will appear here when available.

About this home

List price: $858,000
Original list price: $899,900
Days on market: 92 days
Annual property taxes: $4,335 / year
Year built: 2026

MLS # 20260729134002613321000000 · Listed by Jamie L Maze · Fiv Realty Co Ohio LLC · Listed Aug 1, 2026 · Updated Oct 30, 2026

Property details

Listing overviewMLS-approved public listing fields

MLS number: 226028512
Status: Active
List price: $858,000
Original list price: $899,900
List date: Aug 1, 2026
Property type: Residential
Property subtype: Single Family Residence
County: Delaware
Township: Orange
Subdivision: Evans Farm
Parcel number: 318-210-23-012-000

TaxesMLS-approved public listing fields

Annual property tax: $4,335
Tax year: 2,025

Rooms and interiorMLS-approved public listing fields

Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 3.5
Full bathrooms: 3
Half bathrooms: 1
Living area: 2,994 sq ft
Finished area: 2,994 sq ft
Basement: Yes
Fireplace: Yes

Exterior and lotMLS-approved public listing fields

Lot size: 0.18

ParkingMLS-approved public listing fields

Garage spaces: 2
Garage type: Yes

AssociationMLS-approved public listing fields

HOA fee: $45
Frequency: Monthly
Fee: $45
Fee frequency: Monthly

SchoolsMLS-approved public listing fields

School district: OLENTANGY LSD 2104 DEL CO.

Listing and showing informationMLS-approved public listing fields

Listing office: Fiv Realty Co Ohio LLC
Listing agent: Jamie L Maze
Co-listing agent: Erin Edwards
Public remarks: 5737 Butternut Dr in Evans Farm offers 2,312 square feet (2,994 including the partially finished basement) on a spacious lot, with a light, bright layout and high-end finishes throughout. The first-floor office at the front of the home provides flexible space for work or other use. The open-concept great room features a stacked-stone gas fireplace with a wood mantel, a modern ceiling fan, and large windows that fill the space with natural light. The kitchen includes a large quartz island, custom shaker cabinetry, a tile backsplash, stainless steel range hood, matte black fixtures, and glass pendant lighting, opening to a dining area with sliding door access to the covered patio. Wide-plank wood flooring runs throughout the main level. A half bath completes this floor. Upstairs, 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms include a primary suite with a double-sink quartz vanity, black fixtures, and a large tiled walk-in shower. The finished basement adds a fourth bedroom, a full bathroom with a tiled glass-enclosed shower and dark quartz vanity, a bar, and a recreation space. Additional features include forced-air gas heat, central air conditioning, a poured foundation, cement fiber board exterior, and a 2-car attached side-load garage. The builder is offering a $4,000 appliance allowance and a $2,000 closet allowance. Evans Farm includes shops, restaurants, parks, and walking paths.

Provider and sourceMLS, status, agent, brokerage, and dates

MLS number: 20260729134002613321000000
Status: Active
MLS: Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listing office: Fiv Realty Co Ohio LLC
Listing agent: Jamie L Maze
List date: Aug 1, 2026

Location & neighborhood

Alum Creek Elementary School5/5 stars0.8 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Arrowhead Elementary School4/5 stars1.1 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Olentangy High School5/5 stars1.1 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Heritage Elementary School5/5 stars1.2 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Olentangy Shanahan Middle School5/5 stars1.3 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment

View more schools

Data details

District attendance-area locator

District: Olentangy Local School District

Open source

Census Tract 115.62; Delaware County; Ohio

Area housing context

Data details

U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey

Geography: Census Tract 115.62; Delaware County; Ohio
GEOID: 39041011562
Period: 2020–2024 ACS five-year estimates
Retrieved: Oct 31, 2026
Median owner-occupied value: $529,300 ± $32,206

Census tract estimates describe an area, not a person or household. ACS estimates have sampling error and should not be used to steer, rank protected classes, or make eligibility decisions.

Open source

Housing units: 3,035
Occupied: 97%
Owner occupied: 91%
Median year built: 2014
Median gross rent: $1,191

How this home fits the Lewis Center market

Payment estimate

Estimated monthly housing cost

Home price$Down payment%Loan termInterest rate%Property taxes / year · MLS$Home insurance / year · Estimated$HOA/COA fees / month · MLS$

Estimated monthly payment

$5,102

Estimated loan amount: $686,400

Principal & interest: $4,339
Property taxes: $361
Home insurance: $358
HOA/COA fees: $45

Planning estimate only—not a loan offer, official Loan Estimate, or insurance quote. Confirm actual costs with your lender and other providers.

Estimate details