Active

$235,000

914 Rutter Avenue
Lancaster, OH 43130

4
Beds: 2
Baths: 1,280
Sq Ft: 0.16
Acres: 2 car
Garage

About this home

Welcome home to this solid 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offering more space than you might expect, with several major updates already taken care of! The upstairs windows and HVAC system have been replaced within approximately the last y...

List price: $235,000
Original list price: $259,900
Days on market: 11 days
Annual property taxes: $2,643 / year
Year built: 1966

MLS # 20260914130542368189000000 · Listed by Jessica Lee Moyer · Realty ONE Group Refined · Listed Sep 14, 2026 · Updated Oct 22, 2026

Property details

Listing overviewMLS-approved public listing fields

MLS number: 226034949
Status: Active
List price: $235,000
Original list price: $259,900
List date: Oct 13, 2026
Property type: Residential
Property subtype: Single Family Residence
County: Fairfield
Township: None
Parcel number: 05-33158-500

TaxesMLS-approved public listing fields

Annual property tax: $2,643
Tax year: 2,025

Rooms and interiorMLS-approved public listing fields

Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 2
Full bathrooms: 2
Half bathrooms: 0
Living area: 1,280 sq ft
Finished area: 1,280 sq ft
Basement: Yes
Fireplace: Yes

Exterior and lotMLS-approved public listing fields

Lot size: 0.16

ParkingMLS-approved public listing fields

Garage spaces: 2
Garage type: Yes

SchoolsMLS-approved public listing fields

School district: LANCASTER CSD 2305 FAI CO.

Listing and showing informationMLS-approved public listing fields

Listing office: Realty ONE Group Refined
Listing agent: Jessica Lee Moyer
Public remarks: Welcome home to this solid 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offering more space than you might expect, with several major updates already taken care of! The upstairs windows and HVAC system have been replaced within approximately the last year, while the roof and hot water tank were both replaced in 2025. With these big-ticket improvements already completed, you can focus on making this home your own. Inside, you'll find beautiful hardwood floors in the bedrooms, with additional hardwood waiting to be uncovered beneath the carpeting. The home continues into the walk-out lower level, offering finished living space along with an additional bedroom--perfect for creating a family room, guest space, home office, or a combination that works for you. The outdoor living space is a wonderful bonus. A large rear deck surrounded by mature trees provides a peaceful place to relax or entertain, while the walk-out lower level opens to a covered patio, giving you even more space to enjoy the outdoors. An attached garage, spacious driveway, mature landscaping, and wooded backyard complete the package. With 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, finished lower-level living space, a walk-out basement, beautiful hardwood floors, major recent updates, and multiple outdoor living areas, this home has great bones, plenty of character, and so much to offer its next owner.

Provider and sourceMLS, status, agent, brokerage, and dates

MLS number: 20260914130542368189000000
Status: Active
MLS: Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listing office: Realty ONE Group Refined
Listing agent: Jessica Lee Moyer
List date: Sep 14, 2026

Location & neighborhood

Lancaster High School3.5/5 stars0.6 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Mt. Pleasant Elementary School2.5/5 stars0.7 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Medill Elementary School2.5/5 stars0.9 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Tallmadge Elementary School3/5 stars1.8 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Thomas Ewing Junior High School3/5 stars2.0 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment

Data details

District attendance-area locator

District: Lancaster City School District

Closest schools are ranked by straight-line distance from official NCES public-school building locations. Proximity does not determine attendance assignment or enrollment. Independently verify every school and attendance assignment with the district.

Census Tract 314.01; Fairfield County; Ohio

Area housing context

Data details

U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey

Geography: Census Tract 314.01; Fairfield County; Ohio
GEOID: 39045031401
Period: 2020–2024 ACS five-year estimates
Retrieved: Oct 20, 2026
Median owner-occupied value: $304,600 ± $33,695

Census tract estimates describe an area, not a person or household. ACS estimates have sampling error and should not be used to steer, rank protected classes, or make eligibility decisions.

Open source

Housing units: 989
Occupied: 93%
Owner occupied: 94%
Median year built: 1972
Median gross rent: $1,475

How this home fits the Lancaster market

Median sale price: $274,900
Sale-to-list ratio: 99.4%
Months of inventory: 2.0

Median sale price

Lancaster was a seller-leaning market in September 2026, based on 2.0 estimated months of supply.

Completed September 2026 MLS evidence; incomplete metrics are omitted.

Payment estimate

Estimated monthly housing cost

Home price$Down payment%Loan termInterest rate%Property taxes / year · MLS$Home insurance / year · Estimated$HOA/COA fees / month · Not provided$

Estimated monthly payment

$1,506

Estimated loan amount: $188,000

Principal & interest: $1,188
Property taxes: $220
Home insurance: $98
HOA/COA fees: Not included

“Not included” means no reliable source value was available. Enter a confirmed amount for a fuller estimate.

Planning estimate only—not a loan offer, official Loan Estimate, or insurance quote. Confirm actual costs with your lender and other providers.

Estimate details

Insurance starts at a planning estimate of 0.5% of the home price per year. Items shown as “Not included” are excluded from the total. The estimate does not include closing costs, utilities, maintenance, special assessments, or every lender and escrow charge; mortgage insurance may also apply based on the loan.

Similar homes in Lancaster

View all homes

Back on Market

$237,900

312 N Eastwood Avenue

Lancaster, OH

3 beds2 baths1,612 sq ft

0.5 mi away
Same ZIP
Same single family residence style
Similar price

Price Drop

$239,900

658 Frederick Street

Lancaster, OH

3 beds2 baths1,410 sq ft

0.2 mi away
Same ZIP
Same single family residence style
Similar price

$218,800

838 E Main Street

Lancaster, OH

3 beds2 baths1,176 sq ft

0.7 mi away
Same ZIP
Same single family residence style
Similar price

$224,888

832 E Main Street

Lancaster, OH

3 beds2 baths1,163 sq ft

0.7 mi away
Same ZIP
Same single family residence style
Similar price

Your local advisor

Clint Ford

Team Lead, REALTOR®

+16143525645

Home details

Review this home.

The property record is loading. You can return to current homes or contact the team at any time.

View current homes Talk with an agent

Current information

Loading current details…

The page is ready to use. Provider-backed homes and market evidence will appear here when available.

About this home

List price: $235,000
Original list price: $259,900
Days on market: 11 days
Annual property taxes: $2,643 / year
Year built: 1966

MLS # 20260914130542368189000000 · Listed by Jessica Lee Moyer · Realty ONE Group Refined · Listed Sep 14, 2026 · Updated Oct 22, 2026

Property details

Listing overviewMLS-approved public listing fields

MLS number: 226034949
Status: Active
List price: $235,000
Original list price: $259,900
List date: Oct 13, 2026
Property type: Residential
Property subtype: Single Family Residence
County: Fairfield
Township: None
Parcel number: 05-33158-500

TaxesMLS-approved public listing fields

Annual property tax: $2,643
Tax year: 2,025

Rooms and interiorMLS-approved public listing fields

Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 2
Full bathrooms: 2
Half bathrooms: 0
Living area: 1,280 sq ft
Finished area: 1,280 sq ft
Basement: Yes
Fireplace: Yes

Exterior and lotMLS-approved public listing fields

Lot size: 0.16

ParkingMLS-approved public listing fields

Garage spaces: 2
Garage type: Yes

SchoolsMLS-approved public listing fields

School district: LANCASTER CSD 2305 FAI CO.

Listing and showing informationMLS-approved public listing fields

Listing office: Realty ONE Group Refined
Listing agent: Jessica Lee Moyer
Public remarks: Welcome home to this solid 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offering more space than you might expect, with several major updates already taken care of! The upstairs windows and HVAC system have been replaced within approximately the last year, while the roof and hot water tank were both replaced in 2025. With these big-ticket improvements already completed, you can focus on making this home your own. Inside, you'll find beautiful hardwood floors in the bedrooms, with additional hardwood waiting to be uncovered beneath the carpeting. The home continues into the walk-out lower level, offering finished living space along with an additional bedroom--perfect for creating a family room, guest space, home office, or a combination that works for you. The outdoor living space is a wonderful bonus. A large rear deck surrounded by mature trees provides a peaceful place to relax or entertain, while the walk-out lower level opens to a covered patio, giving you even more space to enjoy the outdoors. An attached garage, spacious driveway, mature landscaping, and wooded backyard complete the package. With 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, finished lower-level living space, a walk-out basement, beautiful hardwood floors, major recent updates, and multiple outdoor living areas, this home has great bones, plenty of character, and so much to offer its next owner.

Provider and sourceMLS, status, agent, brokerage, and dates

MLS number: 20260914130542368189000000
Status: Active
MLS: Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS
Listing office: Realty ONE Group Refined
Listing agent: Jessica Lee Moyer
List date: Sep 14, 2026

Location & neighborhood

Lancaster High School3.5/5 stars0.6 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Mt. Pleasant Elementary School2.5/5 stars0.7 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Medill Elementary School2.5/5 stars0.9 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Tallmadge Elementary School3/5 stars1.8 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment
Thomas Ewing Junior High School3/5 stars2.0 mi straight-line · Nearby public school—not an assignment

Data details

District attendance-area locator

District: Lancaster City School District

Census Tract 314.01; Fairfield County; Ohio

Area housing context

Data details

U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey

Geography: Census Tract 314.01; Fairfield County; Ohio
GEOID: 39045031401
Period: 2020–2024 ACS five-year estimates
Retrieved: Oct 20, 2026
Median owner-occupied value: $304,600 ± $33,695

Census tract estimates describe an area, not a person or household. ACS estimates have sampling error and should not be used to steer, rank protected classes, or make eligibility decisions.

Open source

Housing units: 989
Occupied: 93%
Owner occupied: 94%
Median year built: 1972
Median gross rent: $1,475

How this home fits the Lancaster market

Median sale price: $274,900
Sale-to-list ratio: 99.4%
Months of inventory: 2.0

Median sale price

Lancaster was a seller-leaning market in September 2026, based on 2.0 estimated months of supply.

Completed September 2026 MLS evidence; incomplete metrics are omitted.

Payment estimate

Estimated monthly housing cost

Home price$Down payment%Loan termInterest rate%Property taxes / year · MLS$Home insurance / year · Estimated$HOA/COA fees / month · Not provided$

Estimated monthly payment

$1,506

Estimated loan amount: $188,000

Principal & interest: $1,188
Property taxes: $220
Home insurance: $98
HOA/COA fees: Not included

“Not included” means no reliable source value was available. Enter a confirmed amount for a fuller estimate.

Planning estimate only—not a loan offer, official Loan Estimate, or insurance quote. Confirm actual costs with your lender and other providers.

Estimate details